Mac360 Twitter TweetsSponsorship and Advertising on Mac360Forums Member LoginRegister for Mac360 ForumsFrequently Asked QuestionsYouTube Video WatchDashboard Widget WatchPolls & SurveysMac360 Power Search Options
RSS FeedThe Mac360 Article ArchiveThe Cheap MacWhat's New!Mac Tips & TricksMacintosh User ForumsMac360 Reviews

A Debate Forever? Which Is Cheaper? Mac or PC?

Mac vs. PCBoxers or briefs? Real or not real? Which is better, Mac or PC? Now it’s, “Which is less expensive? Mac or PC?”

There is just no way to put away the never ending Windows and PC vs. the Mac issue. But let’s try anyway.

First, there’s a need to clarify positions. I’ve tried boxers, but prefer briefs. Real or not real? Does it matter? OK, if it matters, then I want real that look, well, unreal.

Second, which is better, Mac or PC? That one has already been settled, right. Remember, this is Mac360, so we’re about Macs, and so what if PCs have a 90-percent market share. It’s going down, while the Mac’s share is going up.

Better is not the same as gargantuan market share—unless we’re talking about the iPod vs. everything else that attempts to play music in your pocket.

Third, at least three times a year, some online publication is required to do a Mac vs. PC cost comparison, or Windows Vista vs. OS X Tiger comparison. I don’t know the exact statute, but I’m sure it was passed during the Clinton-Gore administration.

Common wisdom for many years was that the Mac was a great machine, but much more expensive than a PC. That was then, this is now. In an age when things change overnight, it is not refreshing to see old wisdom die hard.

A few years ago, we figured out that comparably equipped PCs actually cost the same or more than a Mac. No, that’s not a fudge. It’s argumentation. Yes, you can find a PC, many of them, in fact, that are cheaper than a Mac. That’s not the point.

When we buy a computer, most of us don’t just buy the hardware, or the OS—we buy a computer, Mac or PC, to perform certain functions which we require.

Email, browse the internet, word processing, graphics, spreadsheet, music, movies, digital photos. All that.

As with many purchases, we do price comparisons. The myth that Macs cost more than PCs appears to be fading now that Apple has embraced Intel’s chips inside.

Macs being, in general, more secure and less problematic that most PCs has helped shed a number of Mac vs. PC myths.

So, for shoppers who want a computer these days, the choices have expanded, and more often than not, Apple’s flagship Mac lineup shows up on shopping lists. Why? Piece for piece, feature for feature, Macs cost less than PCs. Mostly. Well, sometimes.

According to Scot Finnie of Computerworld, Macs can definitely be less expensive than comparable PCs. Of course, any comparison of prices and costs should include a discussion of TCO—total cost of ownership—except today. Macs cost less to set up, run, maintain, than PCs (save that argument for another day).

Scot does what you’d expect of a mainstream online publication—exploit the masses of readers, Mac and PC. What you, the reader, will get is a three-page article on why Macs are now cheaper than PCs. Sometimes. No comparison is worth anything these days if there’s not an ample supply of hedging, dodging, and weasel words.

Some Mac models, such as the MacBook Pro, and MacPro, can’t even be touched by Dell, piece for piece, feature for feature. Of course, that’s just hardware. There’s little comparison of Windows Vista vs. Mac OS X Tiger. After all, a personal computer isn’t just hardware.

What about what comes on the hardware? For that, we turn to Jeff Wilson of Laptop Magazine, who does a decent shootout of OS X Tiger vs. Windows Vista.

Something really strange is going on in the world these days. As Chris Rock said:

“You know the world is going crazy when the best rapper is a white guy, the best golfer is a black guy, the tallest guy in the NBA is Chinese, the Swiss hold the America’s Cup, France is accusing the U.S. of arrogance, Germany doesn’t want to go to war, and the three most powerful men in America are named ‘Bush’, ‘Dick’, and ‘Colon’.

Computerworld and Laptop Magazine are pointing out that Macs are less expensive than PCs and OS X Tiger is better than Windows. Period. Does it matter? Yes. We’ve waited a long time for a measure of vindication, and here it is, out in the public for all to see. Thank you, Steve. Thank you, Apple. I hereby declare that the debate is over.

Click Here to see reader comments on this article in the Mac360 Forums.

Classy Mac360 PhotoBy Ron McElfresh | My first Mac was the 128k model (from 1984, so I'm old). I live and work in Honolulu, Hawaii. Read my daily commentary on McSolo, check for certified Mac software updates on NoodleMac, and follow me on Twitter.

• Email This Article  •  Follow Mac360 on Twitter
• Posted in the Forum Topics Section

Off Topic Note: Need more Mac software reviews? Check out Page 2 for encore articles. Help support Mac360. Order your copy of Mac OS X Snow Leopard from Mac360 through Amazon. Snow Leopard is $29 for the Single User Upgrade, and only $49 for the 5 User Family Pack Upgrade.

Mac360 posts daily Mac updates on Twitter, too. If you Twitter, give Alexis, Bambi, or Ron a tweet and follow Mac360 on Twitter to get daily Mac tips and tricks.

Chrome
Do Mac users really need another browser that is 1990s ugly?
Tue Nov 10 - Full Article »
xScope
Are you really a graphic professional if you're not using this utility?
Mon Nov 9 - Full Article »
Utility
If you could have only one utility on your Mac, what would it be?
Fri Nov 6 - View Topic »
Flock
Flock is the perfect Mac or PC browser for the social networker.
Thu Nov 5 - Full Article »
Animate
Animation is the domain of experienced graphic professionals, right? Not.
Thu Nov 5 - Full Article »
Diary
Journal or Diary. Your life is worth remembering beyond photographs.
Wed Nov 4 - Full Article »
Snow Leopard
What's in the FORUMS?
Mac360 Link Farm