Mac360 Twitter TweetsSponsorship and Advertising on Mac360Forums Member LoginRegister for Mac360 ForumsFrequently Asked QuestionsYouTube Video WatchDashboard Widget WatchPolls & SurveysMac360 Power Search Options
RSS FeedThe Mac360 Article ArchiveThe Cheap MacWhat's New!Mac Tips & TricksMacintosh User ForumsMac360 Reviews

Apple Designs Their New Products In A Vacuum.

VacuumApple designs win awards. They’re often brilliant designs—from advertising to software to hardware innovation.

Yet, sometimes I pull my hair out when I see Apple doing something that seems so mind numbingly stupid. Does Apple design their products, hardware and software, in a complete vacuum? Yes.

Brilliance doesn’t often see the light of day while toiling away in a committee. Windows Vista, for all the bulk of featuritis, is clearly a product of a committee mentality. Throw enough stuff in the stew, and everyone gets a little of what they like.

On the other hand, Apple seems to work like a secretive chef, a mad scientist in a castle, the geeky nerdy guys in a garage with an idea and few social skills.

I’m convinced that Apple, for all their product brilliance, insight, innovation and engineering skills, pretty much operates in a vacuum. In fact, I’m also convinced that Apple doesn’t really want outside perspective.

Would Dr. Frankenstein go to the village police chief and get his opinion on reanimation? It’s not that Apple doesn’t care about their customers. Maybe they care about doing what they think is best even more than what the customer wants.

A simple case in point, and I’m sure you can come up with a dozen more annoying little things Apple does in every product, is the new Dock in Mac OS X Leopard. In Tiger, click and hold a folder at the right end of the Dock, and a pop up dialog box would reveal the contents of said folder.

Come on, that was very handy, and a great way to navigate through files on your Mac without sloshing over to Tiger’s broken Finder to find files. Create an alias of your Mac’s hard drive, drop it onto the Dock, and navigate until the cows come home.

What’s new in Leopard? No more cows. No more navigation of Dock items. Now we have stacks. I don’t like stacks. I have yet to meet a new Leopard user who likes stacks. What we like is the Grid view. See? Stacks sucks. Grid view is wonderful. Apple is bi-polar about design.

All one has to do is back up a decade to the original iMac. Inexpensive, full of personality, easy to set up and use. Brilliant. So what does Apple do for an encore? Poor candy coated gloss over the iBooks and iMacs and make them look like toys from Fisher Price. When it became clear that Apple couldn’t sell iMacs through Best Buy, I half expected the Mac maker to cut a deal with Toys R Us.

Wil and I argued about whether or not to include his little article on Mac360 about Leopard’s ability to sneak porn onto a Mac. Regardless of how you feel about such unglamorous material, Apple’s use of those features is ideally suited for such prurient actions. It’s as if Apple’s software engineers tried to build in features that would let them get away with some corporate policy against visiting such web sites.

It doesn’t take much to find other lapses within Apple’s streaks of brilliance. How about Mail in the iPod touch? There’s WiFi, but no Mail. Is that ludicrous by design, or did Apple figure no one using an iPod needs to worry about Mail? If so, why have a browser?

I could go on and on but don’t really want to rant. Apple is our favorite bi-polar toy and gadget maker, by far. There are many examples of why it is obvious that Apple designs in a vacuum, and why it works for them. We love their products, Apple makes money hand over fist, and they get more than their share of press and awards. Who can argue with the track record?

I can. There are plenty of spots on the track record of brilliant products through the years, even in their new Golden Age, Apple both delights and mystifies. Can you find a messy spot on Apple’s Leopard, or Mac, or iPod or iPhone? Head to the Mac360 Forums and chew the bone.

Click Here to see reader comments on this article in the Mac360 Forums.

Classy Mac360 PhotoBy Kate MacKenzie | I'm a 15 year Mac user from Brooklyn, New York. I used Windows Vista for a whole year and lived to tell about it. My personal site, PixoBebo, is all about Apple. Follow me on Twitter.

• Email This Article  •  Follow Mac360 on Twitter
• Posted in the Forum Topics Section

Off Topic Note: Even more Mac software reviews are available on Page 2.  Help support Mac360. Order your copy of Mac OS X Snow Leopard from Mac360 through Amazon. Snow Leopard is $29 for the Single User Upgrade, and only $49 for the 5 User Family Pack Upgrade. For mini reviews of Mac software, check Ron’s NoodleMac site. Kate MacKenzie is back after a year of using Windows, and Ron has daily Mac musings on McSolo.

Mac360 posts daily Mac updates on Twitter, too. If you Twitter, give Alexis, Bambi, or Ron a tweet and follow Mac360 on Twitter to get daily Mac tips and tricks.

Chrome
Do Mac users really need another browser that is 1990s ugly?
Tue Nov 10 - Full Article »
xScope
Are you really a graphic professional if you're not using this utility?
Mon Nov 9 - Full Article »
Utility
If you could have only one utility on your Mac, what would it be?
Fri Nov 6 - View Topic »
Flock
Flock is the perfect Mac or PC browser for the social networker.
Thu Nov 5 - Full Article »
Animate
Animation is the domain of experienced graphic professionals, right? Not.
Thu Nov 5 - Full Article »
Diary
Journal or Diary. Your life is worth remembering beyond photographs.
Wed Nov 4 - Full Article »
Snow Leopard
What's in the FORUMS?
Mac360 Link Farm