Mac360 Easy Search
Enter your search keywords below »

Mac360 Power Search
Click below for advanced search options »
Mac360 Archives
By Month, All, Category

Latest Mac Reviews Mac360 Forums New Encore Reviews
Home  »  What's New  »

iMovie ‘08: Big Changes Worth The Price Of iLife.

iMovieiLife ‘08 sold out within hours of debuting at the local Apple Store, and for good reason.

Apple’s loaded the $79 suite with applications, each of which are worth the price of the upgrade.

There wasn’t much wrong with iMovie ‘06, so why did Apple scrap the old version and build a new iMovie from the ground up? Nothing improves without change.

iMovie, more than any application in the iLife suite, is loaded with change. Gone is the simple drag and drop timeline. In is a new interface that’s actually easier to use, though a bit cumbersome when changing from the old iMovie.

Besides the interface, the biggest change is that iMovie is now the tool of choice to store all of your video clips. Think of it as iPhoto for movies. Clips can be arranged just like digital photos in iPhoto.

While Apple evolved iPhoto ‘07 to include Events as an important feature, iMovie becomes the center for video storage and editing with its own Events feature.

When bringing in video (or updating video already captured in iMovie), the new Events function automatically groups video clips based on the day it was shot. Individual video clips can be labeled so they’re easier to find later.

Clips can be marked as favorites, too, which is handy when searching for specific scenes to incorporate into a movie or for export to iDVD.

This isn’t your father’s iMovie. Format problems are a thing of the past, as iMovie can bring in video from nearly anything-- including the hot selling AVCHD video cameras. iMovie doesn’t care much about the source and handles flash based cameras as well as hard drive cameras as well as the standard miniDV cams.

Leave it to Apple to come up with a new feature that shows up not only in iMovie, but in Web Gallery and iPhoto. Skimming is the new buzz word. Drag your mouse pointer across a video clip and the clip runs, faster than real time, if needed.

Just as cool is how iMovie displays a clip. It’s not just the video from the first frame. Think of it as a stretched video clip, with all parts of the scene laid out as film strip. That’s sweet and makes finding video elements much faster and more intuitive.

It’s hard to believe there was that much wrong with the old iMovie that it needed a complete rewrite, but the effort appears worth it. iMovie is worth the price of admission to iLife, which, in itself is a steal at $79.

One thing I had a little trouble adjusting to was the lack of the standard iMovie timeline-- drop in video clips, drop in audio, add transitions, and so on. The functions are still there but require less effort to build. The timeline becomes the project area and you have full access to all the video clips you’ve recorded, not just the most recent.

Transitions and titles are drop ins, too, so there’s not much savings there from the old iMovie, but the editing is done in place on screen, rather than in a framework. What’s also cool is the ability to drag and drop clips, then re-arrange them similar to the slide show in iPhoto.

That’s the basics. Making a movie look more professional is easier in iMovie ‘08, too. Photos from iPhoto drop in easier and you can add zoom and pans and motion much better than the old Ken Burns effect.

Nearly everything is real time in iMovie, including color manipulation, with sliders for saturation, contrast, and more.

Audio controls are no longer stuck in the timeline. They’re in floating palettes which you can move anywhere on the screen.

Taking a cue from the old Garageband, iMovie does voice over capability with enhancement effects and noise reduction, so you can narrate your videos and keep the soundtrack at a lower volume in the background.

Integration and sharing is key to Apple’s current product line with the Mac as the digital hub which produces content that can be used anywhere-- and I mean anywhere. Videos can be exported to QuickTime movies, to YouTube, to the iPhone, to the iPod, to AppleTV, and to .Mac’s web gallery.

Yes, you can send video to iDVD, which is quickly becoming yesterday’s technology.

Apple didn’t surprise with the new iMac line, didn’t say much of anything about the Mac mini getting Core 2 Duo CPUs, but did surprise with iMovie, and the complete integration within and without of the ‘08 suite.

I’m hard pressed to find anything remotely resembling iMovie, at a comparable price, in the PC world. iMove alone is worth more than the cost of admission to iLife ‘08. Everything else is just icing on the cake.

Check out the daily list of our 9 Word mini-Reviews at NoodleMac, and Kate's daily in-depth Mac software reviews at PixoBebo.

   • Article by Ron McElfresh • Published on Wednesday, August 8, 2007
   • Category: What's New • 24 Reader comment(s) • Email This • Digg This • Shop Now
  Page 1 of 1 Page(s) for this article.

Talk Back to Kate, Ron & the Mac360 staff
Mac360 readers talk back. View their comments below or post your own comment to this article. Comments are moderated by the Mac360 staff. Or, post comments in the Mac360 Forums. It's mostly anonymous, there's no obligation, and no cost, so join in-- it's free, fun, low in calories, low in carbs, non-fat, and mildly addictive-- like chocolate and blondes.

Readers Talk Back:
Sambocca says:

I’m not sure how to set that type of thing - sorry mate.

   — Posted on Thu Sep 06 at 11:22 pm by Sambocca

Emmanuel says:

Sambooca thanks, it did work this way.
I have found the source of the problem: there is an option in iPhoto under preferences ‘Connecting camera opens:’ where you can choose iPhoto, iMovie, IMage Capture or no application. I set it to no application so that iPhoto won’t pop up all the time. Is there a way of customizing the opening application per device on Mac OSX? Say, my camcorder would open iMovie, my camera iPhoto and my phone just finder?

   — Posted on Thu Sep 06 at 5:12 am by Emmanuel

Sambooca says:

Try plugging in the camera (set up necessary connection to HD from camera), then open iMovie.

If iPhoto loads 1st - quit it and open iMovie.

iMovie should say “camera detected”. if you get that you’re sorted.

   — Posted on Wed Sep 05 at 6:20 pm by Sambooca

Emmanuel Merali says:

To Natalie and others with the same experience: I have a SR90 as well but when I plug it in, iMovie doesn’t try to import the clips. Instead, it’s iPhotos that opens (!) and of course it cannot import MPEG2 from the camera… Any idea how I can solve that problem?
SR90 - MBP 2.4 Intel - iLife 08. Thanks

   — Posted on Wed Sep 05 at 5:56 pm by Emmanuel Merali

Sambocca says:

Thank you Natalie! Indeed, if you plug the camera (Sony DCR-SR100) in and start iMovie, iMovie sees the camera! Fantastic!

It’s weird that it woun’t import the files from another HD though. You would have thought they’d be the same.

So half the battle is won - now I just have to figure out how to get the 120MB of files on other HD’s into iMovie. Mabe I’ll put them back on the camera, and them through iMovie. Anyway, looks like I won’t have to sell the camera.

   — Posted on Wed Sep 05 at 6:01 am by Sambocca

iggy pence says:

Some of those new hard disk cameras use a crappy proprietary format (Sony, I’m looking at you) that just isn’t easy to port to a Mac.

WARNING: If you by a new video camera and expect to edit your video on iMovie, make sure it is fully compatible before purchase.

   — Posted on Tue Sep 04 at 9:17 pm by iggy pence

Sambocca says:

Max - I have bought iMovie ‘08, and despite what some sites are saying http://www.notebooks.com/2007/08/10/imovie-08-adds-support-for-hdd-dvd-camcorders/#comment-20336

I still can’t import files created by my Sony DCR-SR100 HDD camera. I’m not sure what to do at this point. The hassle factor of the work around is not an option for me - maybe I have to sell the camera and go back to tape?

   — Posted on Tue Sep 04 at 8:09 am by Sambocca

Joseph Elwell says:

Cat Ballou said, “Most Sony cameras are NOT muxed. Most are MiniDV, which works fine in iMovie.”
HOWEVER,

Most Sony CAMERAs are Muxed.
Most Sony VIDEO Cameras are not, they are indeed MiniDV.

Note the difference.

Sony Still Cameras that also shoot video are Muxed.
Sony Video Cameras (that often also shoot poor quality photos) are not Muxed and are MiniDV and work fine in iMovie (always have).

I have both a Sony Camera (DSC-T10) and a Sony Video Camera (can’t recall the model number).

Sony Camera Videos still dont’ work in iMovie 08.
Sony Camcorder movies still do.
Joseph Elwell.

   — Posted on Sat Aug 11 at 8:47 pm by Joseph Elwell

  Page 1 of 3 Page(s) for Comments on this article.  1 2 3 >
     Back To Top

Talk Back to Mac360 and post your own comment

Your comment may be anonymous if you want (it's OK to use a cute name, or something everyone can remember). An email address is only required if you want to be notified of new comments by other posters, and is always shielded from email spam harvesters.

We moderate the comments, so keep it on topic, relevant, worthy, and funny. Or, pick any two. Yes, SPAM links will be deleted, so don't even think about it.

Talk back and enter your comment below:
Your Name:
Your Email:(optional: needed only for comment notification)
Your Location:(optional: your city, state, country)

Enter Your Comment Below:
Remember my personal information?
Notify me of follow-up comments by email?

Please enter the Mac360 "Magic Word" from the image below:



     Back To Top
What's in the FORUMS?
Newest Daily Topics


Also in Mac360
Recent Articles