Mac360 Twitter TweetsSponsorship and Advertising on Mac360Forums Member LoginRegister for Mac360 ForumsFrequently Asked QuestionsYouTube Video WatchDashboard Widget WatchPolls & SurveysMac360 Power Search Options
RSS FeedThe Mac360 Article ArchiveThe Cheap MacWhat's New!Mac Tips & TricksMacintosh User ForumsMac360 Reviews

Mac OS X Called “Toy” By Microsoft Apologist?

Every now and then I run across something that’s more than interesting. It’s bizarre. Funny, even. Immunity’s report on Total Cost of 0wnership can be found Here (a PDF), and listed Here.

Interesting reading. And it’s not even April Fools Day.

To summarize, the report concludes that Microsoft Windows has a lower Total Cost of 0wnership than versions of Linux. Not by much, but lower. Meanwhile, the author, Immunity’s CEO, Dave Aitel, concludes that Mac OS X has a lower TC0 than Microsoft. That’s not surprising, of course, except that Aitel calls Mac OSX a “toy OS.”

”...other than the toy OS Mac OS X, Windows has the lowest TC0 on the market.”

The report also states that hackers, those trying to exploit weaknesses in computer operating systems, are evenly divided between Linux users and Mac OS X users.

“Hackers are rather evenly split between running Linux and running Mac OSX. As much as few professional NASCAR drivers drive Dodge Neons, a negligible amount of skilled hackers use Windows as their primary OS.”

Whew. Windows is as secure and dependable and trustworthy as a Dodge Neon? What does that make Mac OS X? A BMW, or Schwinn?

Where was that research data? I must have missed that amid all the speculation and opinion; in the “research” paper.

And I thought Bill and Monica’s escapdes in the White House were better than fiction. Aitel offers no research material to substantiate the “research” conclusions presented, but calling Mac OS X a “toy” OS was most disturbing.

Do the folks over at Virgina Tech, who put up the 3rd fastest super computer in the world, know that they succeeded with a “toy” operating system? Yes, their overall “total cost” to get the supercomputer running was nearly two orders of magnitude LOWER than the fastest computer, but still…

Who wants to rock the world with a super computer running a “toy” operating system? Why, anyone who’d do such a thing would be laughed out of academia because, uh, well, um…

How much was that super computer again?

Immunity, Inc. seems to be a tight knit group of folks with a slick web site and the ability to create conclusions right out of ether. While the report appears to be well written, research data is somewhat lacking (which is the opposite of the war in Iraq being called “somewhat unsafe.” As in, there isn’t any.

The report’s Summary is revealing:

“Immunity’s findings clearly show that the best platform for your targets to be running is Microsoft Windows, allowing you unparalleled value for their dollar. This result reinforces the fact that its important to consider more than just licensing fees when your targets choose their OS. Indeed, a variety of factors go into their choice, and over time, Windows has demonstrated itself to be the top contender in the, in both the server and the desktop space for Total Cost of 0wnership.”

In all fairness to the author and document, I can write tongue-in-cheek as well as the next guy. Except I had a hard time swallowing the fishy pieces, let alone Summary whale. Maybe it was the first “0” in “0h my gawd. They can’t be serious. Can they?”

Total Cost of 0wnership? It’s often in the eye of the beholder, you know. TC0 has little to do with licensing and much to do with what happens once the computer gets turned on and people start using it. TC0 would require facts, figures, tests, examples, studies, data, data, more data. Wouldn’t it?

Mac OS X may have an aqua-looking bunch of buttons that look so good they’re “lickable” (someone else’s opinion, not mine), but the OS is anything but a “toy.” Isn’t it?

I don’t know. What do you think? Is there anyone over 17 on This Page?

Of course, if you’re one of those Linux or Mac OS X hackers, and you make up most of the hacker community, finding an OS to target would be easy after findings such as those.

Yes, it’s an oddball attempt at humor; the TC"0” and all. But “toy” OS? Then again, perspective is everything, right?

I thought y0u’d agree.

cool smirk

Post your own Comment.

Classy Mac360 PhotoBy Alexis Kayhill | I'm a 20 year Mac user veteran, writer, photographer, wife, and mommy. I live in sunny San Diego with my husband, three children, two dogs, one mean old cat, and an SUV with a back seat full of beach sand. Follow me on Twitter.

• Email This Article  •  Follow Mac360 on Twitter
• Posted in the What's New Section

Off Topic Note: Even more Mac software reviews are available on Page 2.  Help support Mac360. Order your copy of Mac OS X Snow Leopard from Mac360 through Amazon. Snow Leopard is $29 for the Single User Upgrade, and only $49 for the 5 User Family Pack Upgrade. For mini reviews of Mac software, check Ron’s NoodleMac site. Kate MacKenzie is back after a year of using Windows, and Ron has daily Mac musings on McSolo.

Mac360 posts daily Mac updates on Twitter, too. If you Twitter, give Alexis, Bambi, or Ron a tweet and follow Mac360 on Twitter to get daily Mac tips and tricks.

Chrome
Do Mac users really need another browser that is 1990s ugly?
Tue Nov 10 - Full Article »
xScope
Are you really a graphic professional if you're not using this utility?
Mon Nov 9 - Full Article »
Utility
If you could have only one utility on your Mac, what would it be?
Fri Nov 6 - View Topic »
Flock
Flock is the perfect Mac or PC browser for the social networker.
Thu Nov 5 - Full Article »
Animate
Animation is the domain of experienced graphic professionals, right? Not.
Thu Nov 5 - Full Article »
Diary
Journal or Diary. Your life is worth remembering beyond photographs.
Wed Nov 4 - Full Article »
Snow Leopard
What's in the FORUMS?
Mac360 Link Farm